First Time Seeing The Grateful Dead (Band Edition)

Jerry Garcia on stage at Winterland, possibly on December 12, 1972, which was the night I first saw the Grateful Dead (the photo may be from December 10 or 11)

It is a common thread of Grateful Dead fandom and scholarship to formally report the first time you saw the Grateful Dead. The extraordinary detail applied to the history of the band makes that especially easy. Rather than just reflecting on a foggy memory, like "in my college gym in the early 70s," you can say "at SUNY Cortland on April 18, 1971," with certainty that the gig really happened and the date is right. Knowing when and where someone first saw the band gives us insight into their perspective on the group.

Given our level of knowledge about Grateful Dead concerts, this post will note the first time any future member of the Grateful Dead saw the band. Any conclusions you choose to draw from this information are yours to consider.

 

Bob Weir was on the Menlo School football team in the 9th grade, during the 1961-62 school year. By Spring 1965 he was attending the nearby public Menlo-Atherton High School, and played a Spring dance at Menlo School in April 1965. (The photo is from the 1962 Menlo Oak Leaves yearbook [thanks Eric Schwarz {RIP}]. Weir is front row, 5th-L. 8th grader Matthew Kelly is 4th-R, same row)

Modern scholarship has placed the very first performance of the Warlocks at an April, 1965 teenage dance at Menlo School, which had been briefly attended by Bob Weir a few years earlier. At the time, Menlo School was a private boys school, designed as a kind of feeder to nearby Stanford University. The dance would have been a "Menlo Mixer," designed to introduce eligible young Menlo boys to equally eligible young women, from girls' schools such as Castilleja. The dance would not have been open to the general public, nor even likely open to anyone attending a public school. Jerry Garcia, Ron "Pigpen" McKernan, Bob Weir and Bill Kreutzmann never saw the Warlocks or the Grateful Dead perform, as they were members of the band from its beginning until they left the band or until July 1995. I am not aware of Pigpen attending a Grateful Dead concert when he was physically unable to perform.

Magoo's Pizza, 639 Santa Cruz Avenue in Menlo Park, September 1968

ROBERT HUNTER
May 1965 Magoo's Pizza, Menlo Park, CA: The Warlocks
The Warlocks first public performances were at Magoo's Pizza, at 639 Santa Cruz Avenue in Menlo Park. Magoo's was in walking distance of Menlo School, and apparently the Wednesday night shows in May were heavily populated by Menlo students. Many Menlo students were boarders, so they would have had little to do in the evening. Menlo School also housed a college, but only for Freshmen and Sophomores (and the school insisted that it was definitely not a junior college, just a Stanford feeder). So any restrictions on the High School boarders’ activities would not have applied to the college students.

The first Magoo's show was May 5, and the Warlocks also played May 12, 19 and 26. Robert Hunter has generally alluded to seeing the Warlocks at Magoo's, but we don't know exactly which show or shows he may have seen. David Nelson and John Dawson also apparently saw the Warlocks at Magoo's. Hunter never performed on stage with the Grateful Dead, of course, but he was a member if anyone was. He did not join formally forces with the band until September, 1967, however.

Magoo's Pizza, circa 1970, 639 Santa Cruz Avenue, Menlo Park (Girl Scout Troop 19 in front)

PHIL LESH
May 26, 1965 Magoo's Pizza, Menlo Park, CA: The Warlocks
Famously, Jerry Garcia invited Phil Lesh to see The Warlocks at Magoo's. Phil drove down from Berkeley, and had a great time. Afterwards, Garcia sat down with Lesh and told him that they would be pushing out bassist Dana Morgan Jr, and invited Phil to join the Warlocks. The fact that Phil had never played electric bass, nor even guitar, was not a consideration. Garcia offered to teach him. Lesh promptly moved to Palo Alto, and Garcia, Nelson and Eric Thompson gave him enough guitar tips to get started. Lesh played at the Warlocks next gig, a one-off at Frenchy's in Hayward on June 18, 1965.

A promotional photo (probably by Paul Ryan) of The Warlocks at The In Room in Belmont, CA, September 1965. The lettering on the bass drum was by Garcia roommate Rick Shubb.

TOM CONSTANTEN
September, 1965 The In Room, Belmont, CA: The Warlocks
Tom Constanten had met Phil Lesh at UC Berkeley in the Fall of 1961. Constanten was a formally trained pianist, and both Constanten and Lesh were interested in composing modern music. As we know from Jesse Jarnow's excellent Deadcast episode on TC, Constanten had regularly driven Phil from Berkeley to Palo Alto to visit Jerry Garcia and others. So TC had been part of the underground crowd in Berkeley and Palo Alto, even though he didn't play folk music. Constanten had been a student of composition at Mills College and in Europe, before joining the Air Force to avoid the draft.

By 1965, Constanten had enlisted in the Air Force and was stationed in Las Vegas. He had LSD connections from the Bay Area--remember, it was still legal--and shared it with some of his more adventurous friends out in the desert. One weekend in September, he visited Phil Lesh in the Bay Area. Constanten saw the Warlocks at the In Room in Belmont. At the time, Constanten had never played rock music, so it is unlikely that he anticipated ever becoming part of his friend's ensemble. 

In Fall, 1967, Constanten would join the Grateful Dead in the studio, creating some piano effects. By this time, he had played a few fill-in gigs with a Las Vegas rock group called The Demons, but only as a bassist. Nonetheless TC was invited to join the Dead as their organ player in late 1968, relegating Pigpen to singing and playing congas. After a few guest appearances, Constanten would join the group permanently on November 23, 1968, in Oxford, OH, a few days after finishing his Air Force commitments.

MICKEY HART
September 30, 1967 Straight Theater, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Sons Of Champlin
Mickey Hart had a chance meeting with Bill Kreutzmann at a Count Basie show at the Fillmore Auditorium, likely on August 20 or 21, 1967. The pair, along with Hart pal and student Mike Hinton, played drums and talked percussion around the city that night, and agreed to meet up (I discussed this sequence of events in detail in another post). Hart was invited to drop in on a Dead rehearsal, but couldn't find the location. There were some more crossed wires, but Hart managed to get to the Straight Theater on Saturday, September 30, 1967.

After watching the first set, Hart was invited to sit in with the band for the second set. Hart did so, and was immediately asked to join the Grateful Dead. Mythology aside, Hart did not actually appear again with the group until November (there is a photograph of the band performing on October 1, and there is only one drum kit). Nonetheless, Hart's journey from seeing the band to appearing on stage with them was the shortest, even though Phil Lesh appeared more quickly as an established member of the band.

VINCE WELNICK
March 8, 1970 Star Theater, Phoenix, AZ: Grateful Dead/Roxy
In 1970, Phoenix was not at all the major metropolitan area it has become in this century. The Star Theater, also known as the Travel Lodge Theater in The Round, was a 3000-seat venue with the stage in the center of the hall. The Grateful Dead, in the midst of recording Workingman's Dead, had played Saturday night in Santa Monica and then Sunday night in Phoenix. The opening act in Phoenix was the Elektra Records band Roxy, featuring old pal Bob Segarini from the Family Tree.

At the time, Vince Welnick was in a blues-rock band called The Beans, one of the most popular bands in the Phoenix area. Welnick attended the Star Theater show as a fan. About six months later, The Beans would move to the Bay Area, where they would struggle to get heard in the thriving San Francisco scene. On January 20, 1972, The Beans opened for Jerry Garcia and Merl Saunders at the Lion's Share. By March 1972, The Beans would change their name to The Tubes, and go on to great infamy, although they didn't really make any money. Nearly two decades later, after playing with Todd Rundgren and other artists, Welnick was invited to audition with the Grateful Dead, and took over the keyboard chair from the late Brent Mydland. Welnick debuted on September 7, 1990 in Richfield, OH.

KEITH GODCHAUX
August 17, 18 or 19, 1970 Fillmore West, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/New Riders of The Purple Sage
In Jesse Jarnow's exceptional Deadcast episode "Enter Keith Godchaux," Donna Godchaux describes seeing the Grateful Dead with Keith at Winterland on October 5, 1970 (see below). At this time, Donna (then Donna Thatcher) and Keith had mutual friends, but had not met. She said that Keith had already seen the Grateful Dead. Keith lived in Berkeley that Summer, and I am assuming that he saw the Dead at one or more of their Fillmore West shows on August 17, 18 or 19, 1970. It's also possible he saw one of the shows at The Euphoria (aka Pepperland) in San Rafael, on July 14 or 16, 1970. Given that Keith grew up in the Bay Area, it's also possible he could have seen the Grateful Dead even earlier.

Although Donna herself does not know for sure, the implication is that Keith had discovered the Grateful Dead relatively recently. Given that he lived in Berkeley, that points towards having seen the band at Fillmore West in August. Thanks to Donna, by September 1971 Keith would be rehearsing with the Grateful Dead for his October 19, 1971 debut with the band in Minneapolis.

DONNA GODCHAUX
October 5, 1970 Fillmore West, San Francisco, CA: Jefferson Airplane/Grateful Dead/Quicksilver Messenger Service/Hot Tuna/New Riders of The Purple Sage
Donna Thatcher and Keith Godchaux attended a Grateful Dead concert on Monday, October 5, 1970. They fell in love, got married and a year later they would join the Grateful Dead. Donna was invited to join the band at the same time as Keith, but chose to hang back and let him establish himself first. She sang on one song on December 31, 1971, participated in the studio sessions for Ace in Winter 1972, and joined the band on stage full time at the Academy Of Music in Manhattan on March 21, 1972. She would remain in the band until Keith and Donna's final appearance on February 17, 1979 at the Oakland Coliseum Arena.

The October 4 and 5, 1970 Winterland shows were not Bill Graham Presents events. Graham's chief lieutenant, Paul Barratta, had taken over the lease at Winterland, much to Graham's displeasure. He also paid bands more than Graham would pay them at Fillmore West. Although the Dead personally liked Bill, they were perfectly willing to work with his competitors. Barratta was squeezed out of business by early 1971, and Graham took over booking Winterland again. He wasn't happy with any of the bands, but Graham needed the Grateful Dead as much as they needed him, so the whole episode was largely erased from all future recountings of the Dead/Graham saga.

 

Teenage Bruce Hornsby on the Fender Rhodes, playing in Bobby Octane and The Hi-Test Kids somewhere around Earlysville, VA in the Summer of 74 (also Bobby Hornsby (bass) and his future wife Ann (vocals))

BRUCE HORNSBY
March 26, 1973 Baltimore Civic Center, Baltimore, MD: Grateful Dead
19-year old Williamsburg HS graduate Bruce Hornsby has often recounted how he saw the Grateful Dead at William & Mary University in Virginia on September 11 & 12, 1973. At the time, Hornsby was studying music at the University of Richmond.  The Grateful Dead played two nights at William & Mary. At the end of the show, the band announced from the stage that they would be playing a second night, and that the chairs would be removed so that everyone could dance. To all of the fans there, including Hornsby, this was a magical benediction--a great concert followed by an entire concert as an encore the next evening. Hornsby has told this story in interviews a number of times.

In Jesse Jarnow's Deadcast on "Stella Blue," however, a detailed Hornsby interview revealed an unknown twist. College student Hornsby indeed saw the Dead both nights at William & Mary, and it made him a Deadhead for life (among other things, at least). Yet it turns out it wasn't the first time that Hornsby saw the Dead. While still in High School, Hornsby had gone with his brother to see the Grateful Dead at Capital Center outside of Washington, DC, on March 26, 1973 [update 20241018: A Commenter pointed out that the Dead didn't play Cap Center on Mar 26 '73, but rather Baltimore Civic Center]. They were good enough that he went back the next semester when they played in Williamsburg, near his hometown, and it was the Williamsburg shows where Hornsby "got on the bus."

The Grateful Dead Summer 1973 newsletter listed two dates for William & Mary, even though only one was advertised. The second (General Admission) show was announced from the state after the first night.

As for the William & Mary show, of course, the second night had been planned in advance, but that was not revealed to the fans. Why it was handled in this way remains a mystery, since both dates were included the Deadheads newsletter. Bands will often book two nights and not sell tickets to the second night until the first night is mostly sold out, but it's very odd to not even announce the show until the day before. My suspicion is that the University was anxious about the General Admission requirement, and the Dead were adamant, and the compromise was that the first night had to go off successfully.

In early 1974, Hornsby would join a band run by his older brother Robert, called Bobby Octane and The Hi-Test Kids. The band played fraternity parties in and around the University of Virginia for the next year or two, mainly covering Grateful Dead songs. Hornsby went on to an extensive and largely successful career in Los Angeles, and later a substantial solo career which is still ongoing. 

Hornsby has described seeing the Grateful Dead at William & Mary, but has never mentioned that two horn players (Martin Fierro and Joe Ellis) joined in for some numbers, an unprecedented and essentially unique feature of the September 1973 tour. It's not clear whether he didn't notice or didn't recall. 

After meeting the band in 1987, Hornsby had jammed with the Dead on stage a few times. In August 1990, at a McDonald's in Walnut Creek (likely on N. California Blvd), prior to a Hornsby concert at Concord Pavilion, Jerry Garcia asked him to join the Grateful Dead to replace Brent Mydland. Hornsby turned down the offer. He did agree to help the Dead in any way he could, however, and thus became an adjunct member for the next 18 months or so.

BRENT MYDLAND
December 31, 1978 Winterland, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Blues Brothers/New Riders of The Purple Sage
Brent Mydland was from Brentwood, CA, near Antioch, although he ended up graduating High School in Concord, having been kicked out of his Brentwood high school (Liberty HS) for having long hair. He played in various local ensembles, before ending up touring with the Batdorf & Rodney duo in 1974 and '75, thanks to his friendship with bassist Rick Carlos. Afterwards, Brent made a forgettable album with the group Silver (which included John Batdorf). In late 1977, Carlos once again invited Brent to audition, this time for the Bob Weir Band, supporting Weir's new album Heaven Help The Fool. Brent toured with Weir in 1978.

The Jerry Garcia Band and The Bob Weir Band made a brief tour of the Pacific Northwest on the last weekend of October 1978. Garcia heard Brent play with Weir, and later said to Bob, "this guy might work." The Dead were unhappy with Keith Godchaux, and Keith and Donna's marriage was struggling, and it was clear, if unspoken, that a replacement would have to be found for both of them. Life would be easier for the Dead if a single performer could cover both the keyboards and the harmony singing. 

Sometime prior to New Year's, Weir had let Brent know that there might be some opportunity for him in the Grateful Dead. Keith and Donna Godchaux were also members of the Jerry Garcia Band, but they had booked no dates after November 3, 1978, clear sign in retrospect that change was afoot. Things were no doubt complicated by the fact that some late November Dead dates were canceled due to Garcia's illness, and had to be made up in January of 1979. Nonetheless, Brent and his girlfriend were invited to see the Grateful Dead at the gigantic party that closed down Winterland for the final time. I was there, too, and in fact the music wasn't that great, and the show wasn't really that well run, but if you were backstage wondering if this was a band you might join, those things probably didn't matter.

We are really in Thoughts On The Dead territory here, and we need Time Sheath technology that is not yet available to us. Yet I cannot help but wonder if some sort of Artificial Intelligence Facial Recognition software cannot be applied to any backstage footage, outtakes and all, to see if we can identify Brent peering into his own future.

 

 

January 30-31, 1970: Grateful Dead/Family Dog Merger (Not To Be) [FDGH VI]

 

 

Chet Helms, late 60s (also: some guy)

From the very beginning, the Grateful Dead had always tried to become a self-contained organism. One of their goals was to have some sort of permanent venue, where they could rehearse and perform at will. In the earliest days, the band even strove to live in such a place, although they only achieved it briefly at Rancho Olompali in Marin in the early Summer of 1966. Even though the band members' expanded personal lives pushed against communal living, the band was still looking for a room of its own. In old 1967 interviews, you can read about a mythical "Deadpatch." In 1968 the Dead took over the Carousel. These ideas persisted, and after 1995 the plan was resuscitated with "Terrapin Station," a permanent installation in San Francisco proper. 

In early 1970, however, it nearly happened. The Grateful Dead office nearly merged with Chet Helms and the Family Dog on The Great Highway. The Dead and the New Riders had played the beautiful old ballroom on 660 Great Highway (near 48th and Balboa) many times in 1969, and they always played well. Why not make it home? The Family Dog would have had a "House Band" that ensured some financial security, and Jerry Garcia, Owsley and the Grateful Dead could have the run of the place. If they had released Workingman's Dead and had been anchored at a home base, the arc of their career might have been different.

Dennis McNally wrote about it, but it mostly gets forgotten. The very weekend that manager Lenny Hart was moving the offices, the Grateful Dead were getting busted down on Bourbon Street. On top of that, while Lenny Hart was moving, he wasn't showing Chet Helms the books, and Helms realized that Lenny's management was bent. Helms called off the merger. Calling it off was a sad but shrewd decision, since Hart was stealing from the Dead and would have stolen from Helms. Helms was counting on the Dead's capital infusion, and all they had was debt. 

The Grateful Dead/Family Dog merger never reached fruition. Nor could it have worked, really, given the financial realities. But let's consider it anyway, as a path not taken. 

The Grateful Dead, 1970: State Of Play
The Grateful Dead had been underground rock legends since their inception. More people had probably heard of them, however, than actually heard them. Their first three albums had not been successful. Aoxomoxoa, their third album, had cost over $100,000 and gone way over budget, so even if record sales were adequate, they wouldn't see any money from it for some time. The double album Live/Dead, however, constructed in parallel, had been released in November of 1969. It got spectacular reviews, probably got some FM airplay at new stations around the country, and probably sold a little bit.

Grateful Dead manager Lenny Hart had renewed the Grateful Dead's contract with Warner Brothers in 1969. Their initial 4-album deal would have expired with Live/Dead, but Lenny had extended it. The band didn't even know they were up for renegotiation. Hart probably pocketed the advance, since after he was fired it was revealed that he had stolen over $150,000. Meanwhile, the Dead were touring hard, winning fans everywhere they went, but without any strategy. Hart took gigs for the band as they were offered, and the Dead's touring schedule was not efficient, so they probably wasted money traveling unnecessarily to make gigs.

Meanwhile, the ambitious Jerry Garcia had numerous other plans. He was learning pedal steel guitar, and backing songwriter John Dawson in the New Riders of The Purple Sage. There was also a nascent plan to have some sort of country "Revue," seemingly called Bobby Ace And The Cards Off The Bottom Of The Deck. An ensemble that included Garcia, Bob Weir, the New Riders, Peter Grant and possibly others would play honky-tonk music and perhaps some originals, broadly in the style of the Porter Wagoner Show, which Weir and Garcia regularly watched on syndicated television. There was a lot going on in Deadland, and I'm not even counting soundman Owsley Stanley's mad experiments and Alembic Engineering's newly modified electric instruments.

In the end, the Family Dog benefit was moved from Winterland to the smaller Fillmore West

Family Dog, 1970: Plans and Portents
In 1969, the Family Dog on The Great Highway had mostly featured San Francisco bands as weekend headliners, while also open many nights of the week for a variety of community and entertainment events. Economically, the Dog had been a dismal failure. Undercapitalized to start with, the organization also had to get out from under a $5000 IRS tax lien, a substantial sum in 1969. By year's end, the Dog told the San Francisco Examiner that they were $50,000 in debt. A benefit concert, held at the Fillmore West of all places, had helped to keep the Great Highway operation afloat. At the time Helms promised, albeit vaguely, to have a new plan for the next year that focused on larger weekend events. The New Year had opened with some modest bookings the first two weekends (January 2-3 and 9-10), and then the Family Dog was dormant until month's end.

All the evidence we have for the first part of 1970 points to an ambitious, sensible plan by the Family Dog on the Great Highway. Helms was never explicit about these plans, however, for reasons that will become clear. I have had to piece together the outlines of the Family Dog's new arrangement from external evidence and a few after-the-fact reminisces, some of them from anonymous sources on Comments Threads (@anoldsoundguy, always hoping you can weigh in). I am providing my best guess, always subject to modification, and I should add that even if I am largely correct, Chet Helms and the Family Dog may not have used the modern terminology with which I describe the approach. Nonetheless, here's what all the evidence points to for the Family Dog's planned road to stability, even if they never got very far.

The Family Dog on The Great Highway, at 660 Great Highway, ca. 1969

The Family Dog on The Great Highway, 660 Great Highway, San Francisco, CA
The Family Dog was a foundation stone in the rise of San Francisco rock, and it was in operation in various forms from Fall 1965 through the Summer of 1970. For sound historical reasons, most of the focus on the Family Dog has been on the original 4-person collective who organized the first San Francisco Dance Concerts in late 1965, and on their successor Chet Helms. Helms took over the Family Dog in early 1966, and after a brief partnership with Bill Graham at the Fillmore, promoted memorable concerts at the Avalon Ballroom from Spring 1966 through December 1968. The posters, music and foggy memories of the Avalon are what made the Family Dog a legendary 60s rock icon.

In June, 1969, Chet Helms had opened the new Family Dog on The Great Highway, at 660 Great Highway in San Francisco. It was on rocky Ocean Beach at the edge of the city--indeed, the edge of North America--far from downtown, far from Marin and Berkeley, and not even that accessible to the Peninsula by freeway. The former Edgewater Ballroom, built 1926, was a wonderful little venue. The official capacity was under 1500, though no doubt more people were crammed in on occasion, and it was smaller than the old Fillmore. Bill Graham, meanwhile, had moved out of the old Fillmore into the larger, more freeway-friendly Fillmore West, and he still dominated the rock market. Helms had opened the Family Dog on The Great Highway on June 13, 1969, with a sold-out Jefferson Airplane show, but the going had been rocky for the balance of the year.

 

One of the only photos of the interior of the Family Dog on The Great Highway (from a Stephen Gaskin "Monday Night Class" ca. October 1969)

Step 1: Weekends Only
From January 30, 1970 onward, the Family Dog on The Great Highway only booked weekend shows, and the headliners were established bands with albums. It was a fact of San Francisco that just about all the headliners were Bay Area bands, as San Francisco was at the center of rock music at the time. So the Family Dog was in a unique position to feature largely local acts while still having headline bands with albums. In many cases, the albums were successful, too. So it wasn't exactly a "local" venue, but definitely home-grown. San Francisco is an insular place, so this was a potentially viable strategy. The Dog wasn't opposed to hiring touring bands, but they were more expensive, and in any case preferred the higher-profile Fillmore West.

Here and there the Family Dog was used on weekdays for a few events, but it stopped trying to be a community center. Weekend ticket prices were typically $3.50. That was high, but not excessive. The shows were booked in order to make a profit for the bands and the venue. The headliners in February and March read like it was 1967 again: Jefferson Airplane, Quicksilver, Steve Miller, Big Brother, the Grateful Dead, Lee Michaels and Country Joe and The Fish. All those bands were from the Avalon days, but they all had record contracts and current or forthcoming albums, too. The first weekend booking was Jefferson Airplane, on January 30-31, 1970.

Step 2: New Finance
Clearly, the Family Dog was recapitalized by the end of January. Although Chet Helms had loyal support from the local bands that had played the Avalon, they were all working bands as well. Helms could not have booked the bands that he did from February through April without some cash on hand. It is the source of the new finance that has never really been explained, and that I have had to infer. Anyone who has insights or knowledge into this area, please Comment or email me. I am noting in advance that these are my most plausible guesses, and I am open to substantial corrections.

As near as I can tell, Helms collected contributions from local hippie entrepreneurs. My guess is that most of them sold products that were--shall we say--not subject to taxation, nor available in stores. Similarly, these same entrepreneurs did not want their names publicly identified as a source of cash.  

Step 3: A New Implied Business Model
Chet Helms is often unfairly criticized as a poor businessman, because he has always been compared with Bill Graham. Pretty much anyone wasn't as good a businessman as Graham, certainly not in the rock and roll business. Helms had his flaws as a business operator, but he was very innovative, and in many ways I believe his approach to the Family Dog on The Great Highway was innovative as well. For simplicity's sake, I will use modern terminology to explain what appear to have been the outlines of his plan. I'm sure that Helms himself would have used different terms, but I'm not aware of a public or written statement. 

The traditional criticism of Helms' business practices vis-a-vis Graham was that Bill charged everybody for tickets, and Chet let all of his friends in for free. By 1970, I do not believe that was the case. Based on Comment Threads, it appears that the Family Dog doorman had a Rolodex (address card file), and if your name was in that Rolodex, you got let in for free. Many of the names on that Rolodex were the hippie entrepreneurs that had laid out cash to keep the Dog going. In return, they got in for free whenever they wanted.

Was this a new model? Not really. It's how every museum in America was run, and largely still is. It's true that museums are not-for-profit and donations are tax-deductible, but Chet may have got to that over time. Certain people in the hippie community had money, and they contributed more of it in return for guaranteed admission. Today, the venerable Freight And Salvage club in Berkeley runs on this model. It's a very sound plan that could have worked.

SF Examiner columnist Jack Rosenbaum mentioned on Wednesday, February 25, that the Grateful Dead had taken over the Family Dog on the Great Highway (although in fact Chet Helms had backed out already, and the deal was off)

Step 4: A High Profile Partnership
It seems that Helms wasn't going to do this alone. He had a partnership lined up, and his partners were going to be no less than the Grateful Dead. The Dead were going to move their operation from Novato to the Family Dog on The Great Highway. It some ways this may have been designed as a replay of the Carousel Ballroom, but with an experienced producer like Helms as part of the team. The New Riders of The Purple Sage had played numerous dates at the Family Dog in 1969, so Jerry Garcia clearly liked the place. Remember, there were only a few, tiny rock clubs to play in the Bay Area at the time, so the 1000>1500 capacity Dog left room for the Riders to consider building their own audience.

Of course, the Dead and the Family Dog did not merge. The merger was scheduled for early February  1970, and that is precisely when everything fell apart for the Grateful Dead. The band was busted in New Orleans, putting the freedom of soundman Owsley Stanley in great jeopardy, due to a prior LSD arrest. More critically, the Dead discovered that manager Lenny Hart (drummer Mickey Hart's father) was an outright crook, and had ripped the band off for $150,000, an enormous sum at the time. The Grateful Dead were dead broke, without a manager and without a soundman. Dennis McNally mentions the abandoned merger in his epic Dead history A Long Strange Trip, but it is remarked on almost in passing amidst all the other tumult. McNally:

As the Dead had been busted in New Orleans [January 31], [Lenny Hart] had been in the process of moving their office from Novato to the Family Dog on the Great Highway, with Lenny to become manager of the FDGH as well as the Dead, and with Gail Turner to be the FDGH secretary as well as Lenny's. The idea of sharing space with the Dead appealed to Chet Helms, but became evident to him and Gail that the numbers weren't adding up and that there had to be at least two sets of books. Before anyone in the band even knew, Lenny moved the office back to Novato. [p.360-361].

So just as Jefferson Airplane are re-opening the Family Dog, the Grateful Dead office is relocating to merge their businesses. Helms, while not Bill Graham, was neither a sucker nor a crook. Lenny Hart would have stolen from him, too, so he canceled the merger. The Grateful Dead themselves were probably unclear about what was happening, in between recording Workingman's Dead, worrying about Owsley and constantly performing.  But the planned merger can't have been a secret in the local rock community. On Wednesday, February 25, Examiner columnist Jack Rosenbaum (the Ex's Herb Caen, if you will), had an item (posted above):

Love Generation: to help the Grateful Dead rock group build a defense fund for their pot-bust in New Orleans, Bill Graham staged a benefit Monday night [Feb 23] at Winterland, raising a tidy $15,000. So-0, the Grateful Dead have taken over the Family Dog rock-dance auditorium on the Great Highway--in competition with Graham.

Rosenbaum was wired to local gossip, but not the freshest of rock news. Now, thanks to McNally (writing in 2003), we know that by late February the Dead-Dog deal was off. Still, the point here was that the word was around and had gotten to a city paper columnist, even if it was already a stale item.

1

Kleiner Perkins HQ on Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park, a mile or so from the former site of Perry Lane

A Brief Reflection
It's world-changing to imagine Jerry Garcia and the Grateful Dead with their own performance venue doubling as a rehearsal hall, on the beach in San Francisco. It's important to remember that it could not have happened. Lenny Hart had organized the deal, Helms had seen through the scam, and both entities were fairly broke. It's ironic that the local dealers probably loved the idea of supporting a partnership with the Dead, but could not publicly acknowledge themselves. The Dead/Dog merger could never have worked in the form in which it was conceived.

But let's take a moment to respect Helms for his forward thinking. The Edgewater Ballroom, which evolved into the Family Dog on The Great Highway, was torn down in 1973. But, just for a moment, let's say there was still an elegant 1500-capacity dance hall at Ocean Beach. What does the funding structure look like in 2022?

Proposition:

• A Jam Band palace at Ocean Beach, on the edge of San Francisco
• The Great Highway converted to pedestrian only access (or nearly so)
• Cannabis entrepreneurs providing capital, and now able to publicly sponsor the hall
• For a membership fee, you would be guaranteed entrance without needing a ticket (within the confines of safety laws, of course)
• Participation and partnership from and with the Grateful Dead organization

Ocean Beach is near Interstate 280. You could head South and turn off at the Sand Hill Road exit into Menlo Park, where Kleiner Perkins and all the other Venture Capitalists started the tech boom. Kleiner Perkins helped found Amazon, Google and Twitter, among many other companies. You could arrange infinite financing on your iPhone before you even got to Sand Hill Road--before Crystal Springs, honestly--and just sign the deal when you got out of the car. Helms was just ahead of his time by 50 years or so.

It wasn't to be. Jefferson Airplane re-opened the Family Dog on Friday, January 30, but the plan was already crumbling around the Dog.

Appendix
Grateful Dead and The New Riders of The Purple Sage at the Family Dog on The Great Highway
The Grateful Dead and the New Riders of The Purple Sage played many shows at the Family Dog. The band and particularly Garcia must have enjoyed playing there, or Lenny Hart wouldn't have made the proposition to merge the operations. 

August 1, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Light Show Strike [Grateful Dead canceled] (Friday)

August 2-3, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Albert Collins/Ballet Afro-Haiti (Saturday-Sunday)

August 12 or 13, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: New Lost City Ramblers/New Riders of The Purple Sage (Tuesday or Wednesday)
There is some uncertainty as to whether the Riders played on Tuesday (12th) or Wednesday (13th). Garcia and Nelson jammed with Mike Seeger and the New Lost City Ramblers for the encores. There was also an August 14 jam with the New Lost City Ramblers and Mickey Hart and The Hartbeats. It's not clear if that was a public event, or just a musicians jam.

August 19, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: New Riders of The Purple Sage (Tuesday)
For New Riders setlists during this period, see here.

August 28, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Mickey Hart and The Hartbeats/New Riders of The Purple Sage (Thursday)

August 29-30, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/New Riders of The Purple Sage/Commander Cody and His Lost Planet Airmen/Rubber Duck (Friday-Saturday)

September 6, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Jefferson Airplane/Grateful Dead (Saturday)

September 7, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: jam (Sunday)
Garcia, Jorma Kaukonen, Jack Casady and others had some kind of jam on Sunday, September 7. It's unclear if other bands played.   

September 11, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Purple Earthquake/Johnny Mars Blues Band/Wisdom Fingers/Osceola (Thursday)
There is a Grateful Dead tape fragment dated September 11. There is no other evidence that the Dead played the Family Dog, but it was "New Band Night" so maybe they showed up.  

October 22, 1969 Family Dog on the Great Highway, San Francisco, CA New Riders of the Purple Sage/Lazarus  (Wednesday) Ecological Ball

November 1-2, 1969, Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Danny Cox/Golden Toad (Saturday-Sunday)

November 18, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: New Riders of The Purple Sage (Tuesday)

November 19, 1969 Fillmore West, San Francisco, CA: Family Dog Benefit with Steve Miller Band/New Riders of The Purple Sage/Barry McGuire and The Doctor/Humble, Mumble, Fumble and Dumble (formerly Big Brother and The Holding Company) (Wednesday)

November 22-23, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: New Riders of The Purple Sage/Anonymous Artists of America/Devil's Kitchen (Saturday-Sunday)

November 27, 1969 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Cleveland Wrecking Company/New Riders of The Purple Sage/Lamb/Deacon and The Suprelles/East Bay Sharks/Pitschell Players/Morning Glory Theater Free City Puppet Ball (Thursday)

February 4, 1970 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Jefferson Airplane/Grateful Dead/Santana/Kimberly "A Night At The Family Dog" (Wednesday)
There was also a rehearsal/soundcheck on Tuesday, February 3.

February 27-March 1, 1970 Family Dog on The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Commander Cody and His Lost Planet Airmen (Friday-Sunday)

March 18, 1970 Family Dog on the Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Rolling Thunder (Shoshone Medicine Man)/Hot Tuna/New Riders of the Purple Sage  [Benefit for the Sons of Thunder] (Thursday)

April 17-19, 1970 Family Dog On The Great Highway, San Francisco, CA: Mickey Hart and The Hartbeats/Bobby Ace And The Cards Off The Bottom Of The Deck/Charlie Musselwhite/New Riders Of The Purple Sage (Friday-Sunday)

[For current links to all the listed Garcia and Dead shows at the Family Dog on The Great Highway, see the Tracker here]

James And The Good Brothers: Overview and Performance Listings, 1970-71 (Next Riders I)

An ad from the Oct 16, 1970 Berkeley Barb for upcoming shows at The New Orleans House. James and The Good Brothers "Courtesy Of The Grateful Dead" are booked for the weekend of October 23-24

James And The Good Brothers
James And The Good Brothers were a Canadian acoustic trio who were an extended part of the Grateful Dead family. Guitarist James Ackroyd had teamed with twin brothers Brian and Bruce Good, on guitar and autoharp, respectively. All sang, and their music was in a country-folk style, but without a pronounced Southern twang. The trio had met the Grateful Dead when they played on the infamous Festival Express cross-Canadian tour. The Dead invited them to San Francisco, and the group came down to San Francisco, where the Dead helped them get gigs.

James and The Good Brothers sang original songs, more or less in the vein of Crosby, Stills and Nash or America. They were more country than either of those bands, but since they had Canadian accents rather than Southern ones, their music had a different resonance with  American listeners. Also, since the Good Brothers used an autoharp, a rarely used instrument, their music had a different feel to it. It's no surprise that James And The Good Brothers were signed to Columbia, since major label record companies were snapping up any band in the CSN vein. 

According to Bruce and Brian Good, in a 2015 interview, they went into one of the "music cars" on the Festival Express train, and wound up picking with Garcia. They played bluegrass with him, and Garcia took a liking to them. Per Bruce, at the end of the train tour, the Dead would invite them to San Francisco record an album at their studio. Now, the story is a little more complicated than that, but for a broad brush 40-some years later, it was an accurate description.

James And The Good Brothers would record at Wally Heider's with Grateful Dead engineer Betty Cantor. Jerry Garcia and Bill Kreutzmann likely played on the initial sessions, although their tracks were not used on the final album. Ultimately, parts of the album seems to have been re-recorded in Toronto. Columbia would release the James And The Good Brothers album in November, 1971.

By March, 1971, however, the band had opened a weekend for the New Riders Of The Purple Sage at Fillmore West (on February 25-28). When they had played there, Jerry Garcia (pedal steel guitar), Jack Casady ("balalaika" bass) and Spencer Dryden (drums) had joined the trio. Now, Garcia and Dryden were playing with the New Riders that night anyway, but the fact that a trio of heavyweights joined them got the band mentioned in a review. It also made their status as Grateful Dead "family members" apparent. 

Ultimately, James Ackroyd would stay in California, and the Good Brothers would return to Canada, where they had a successful musical career along with their banjo-playing younger brother Larry.

Rock Music Economics ca. 1970: New and Next Riders
In early 1970, the Grateful Dead had been in dire economic straights. In March, 1970, they had fired their manager Lenny Hart because he had absconded with $150,000 of the band's money, an enormous sum at the time. Their previous studio album had run way, way over budget, so they weren't getting royalties from that. The recently-released Live/Dead was promising, but it wasn't going to be any kind of conventional hit. All of the band members were functionally broke. Throughout 1970, under the guidance of road manager Sam Cutler, the Grateful Dead played there way back into solvency. Along the way, they had put out an album that was cheaply recorded and widely played on FM stations across the country. The album in turn increased concert receipts, so the Dead were finally doing pretty well. By the end of the year, band members had bought cars, and they had stopped living in overcrowded communal quarters.

The Grateful Dead and Jerry Garcia did things in their own manner, but they always had an entrepreneurial streak. Unhappy with Bill Graham and Chet Helms, they had taken over the Carousel Ballroom in 1968. Though it had failed, they had nearly merged with Helms and his Family Dog in early 1970, until Helms had demurred at the idea of being in business with Lenny Hart. The Dead had also been instrumental in the formation of Alembic Engineering, creating a business where Ron Wickersham, Owsley Stanley, Bob Matthews and others could focus on high quality sound gear for live performance. Various other schemes had gotten floated over the years (google "Deadpatch"), even if they hadn't gotten off the ground. So Garcia and the Dead always had big schemes, even if they didn't go the way that they planned.

One of Jerry Garcia's unconventional enterprises was appearing as a sideman in a group completely separate from his main band. Garcia had been playing pedal steel guitar for the New Riders of The Purple Sage since Summer 1969. It was rare enough for rock stars to play outside their own group for more than a single recording session, but Garcia had a whole different band. The only real comparison was Jorma Kaukonen and Jack Casady in Hot Tuna, but Jorma and Jack led that band. Garcia actually played a different instrument in the Riders and let John Dawson be the frontman. 

Still, Garcia's unorthodoxy had gotten the New Riders noticed. The Riders opened for Dead shows and played around the Bay Area, to the extent Garcia was available. By the Summer, Garcia knew that in order for the New Riders to thrive, they would need their full-time pedal steel guitarist, and he had spotted Buddy Cage. Cage was on the Festival Express tour playing with Ian and Sylvia Tyson's band Great Speckled Bird. Some sort of invitation resulted from the train trip, and Cage would join the New Riders in November of 1971, after relocating to the Bay Area. 

I don't think Garcia reflected much on what he was doing, but I am confident that he was conscious of what he was trying to do. Unlikely as Garcia's efforts with the New Riders were in the world of hippie rock, they were pretty common in the worlds of jazz or country music. Plenty of jazz musicians would play around New York outside of their usual combos, bringing attention to lesser known musicians. Similarly, most jazz fans had bought a jazz album by someone they hadn't heard of just because another, more famous musician was on the record. 

Generally, when a Nashville star toured, they usually brought along an ensemble of other singers and players, helping to build those careers. Porter Wagoner, a huge country star since the 1950s, had a singer in 1965-66 named Jeannie Seely, who was part of his show and duetted with him. No one really remembers her. But we all remember Dolly Parton, who replaced Seely in the Wagoner show (on TV and on tour) from 1966-74. So when the New Riders played on a Dead show, with Garcia in the band, there was an existing business model.

Other wings of the fledgling Grateful Dead enterprise were benefiting from the New Riders. Sam Cutler was organizing tours and booking shows, Jon McIntire was working with the record companies and Alembic was providing sound gear. With another band "in development," all these enterprises had a chance to benefit. In turn, those enterprises gave the New Riders access to people and equipment they would not have had without the Dead connection. So when Garcia invited James and The Good Brothers to come to San Francisco to help them make a record, he wasn't just being friendly--it was part of a plan.

Although only partly articulated, the pillars of the early 1970s Grateful Dead empire was built on three legs:

Generosity: at his core, Garcia was a generous man when it came to music and musicians. He didn't need much--a guitar, an amp, something to smoke, and a gig--and he was going to share what else he had. Garcia also implicitly realized that his status could help other musicians without any harm to his own future, so why not be generous? Garcia's attitude defined the entire Grateful Dead enterprise: if your own needs are met, look out for someone else.

Community: some parts of the Grateful Dead team were specifically interested in building community. Jon McIntire was an important voice here. Blair Jackson and David Gans quote him as saying his principal interest was in building community, not business (This Is All A Dream We Dreamed, p.214). The Grateful Dead grasped early that their own audience could be self-sustaining, if they were treated properly. In general, the Dead were interested in creating a tiny ecosystem where goods and services were largely supplied by an interlocking group of people. This could keep a lot of friends and family employed, without those people having to be musicians or have other rare skills. Old friends and band girlfriends could look after the warehouse or answer phones or any number of other roles, and they did.

Transactional: in order to function safely in the Capitalist world, the Grateful Dead had to thrive in it. Garcia, nor Cutler, nor McIntire, had no problem with any of this, beyond not wanting to wear a suit and tie. The businesses created by the Grateful Dead--, booking, tour management, recording studios, live sound equipment--still needed additional customers beyond the Dead. At the same time, the clients of these enterprises (Out Of Town Tours, Alembic, etc) benefited from the expertise of the likes of Sam Cutler, Jon McIntire or Ron Wickersham. 

So when Garcia invited James And The Good Brothers to come to San Francisco, it went beyond a musician helping some guys he liked who were a bit lower on the ladder than he was. Garcia was providing fuel for the Grateful Dead economy to thrive, and James And The Good Brothers were going to benefit. I'm not imagining this--Garcia would do exactly the same thing a few months later when he invited David Grisman, Richard Loren and the Rowan Brothers to relocate from Manhattan to Stinson Beach. On a larger scale, these pillars were the thinking behind Round Records. Garcia didn't have to risk his capital on albums by bluegrass bands, Robert Hunter or electronic composers, but he did. 

So the invitation for James And The Good Brothers wasn't just a generous suggestion by Jerry Garcia, but a test run of Garcia's new recognition that the success and fame of the Grateful Dead could be a magnet for the success of others. Thus, reviewing the performance history of James And The Good Brothers in the Bay Area isn't just archival, but a roadmap for Garcia to replicate his contribution to the New Riders on to another band, a Next Riders. It was only partially successful, but it was no less informative for that.

James and The Good Brothers: Canada 1970

Brian and Bruce Good were from Richmond Hill, Ontario, part of greater Toronto. They had formed a country-folk quartet called the Kinfolk with Marty Steiger and Margaret McQueen, playing traditonal country with a distinct Canadian flavor. They played the coffeehouses in Toronto and fairs in Ontario. By early 1970, two members of the Kinfolk had left (well, McQueen married Bruce, but she did leave the band). The Good Brothers would meet guitarist James Ackroyd by chance in a Yorkville (Toronto) coffee shop called The Penny Farthing around February of 1970. Ackroyd, from Winnipeg, had been the lead guitarist in groups such as Barry Ennis and The Keymen and The Knack. The trio re-named themselves James And The Good Brothers. After playing around Ontario, the trio was then invited on the Canadian Express Train Tour with the Grateful Dead, Janis Joplin and others

April 3, 1970 Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto, ON Grand Funk Railroad/James and The Good Brothers

The band's initial performance was, apparently, opening for Grand Funk Railroad at the Maple Leaf Gardens. Presumably they also played other shows around Ontario. James And The Good Brothers had been advertised as part of the Festival Express Tour as early as May 4 (from a wire service article in the Los Angeles Times).

June 27-28, 1970 Canadian National Exhibition, Toronto, ON Festival Express Tour

It's unclear if James And The Good Brothers played one day at the stadium or on both.

June 28, 1970 Coronation Park, Toronto, ON (Sunday) Free Concert

The Grateful Dead agreed to play a free concert in a Toronto park on Sunday afternoon, between the paid shows, in order to assuage the feelings of hippies who thought music should be free. The Dead and The New Riders played, but it's unclear who else performed. Since James And The Good Brothers were an acoustic trio, it may have been easier for them to play the free show in the park.

 

After the Toronto show, the musicians boarded the infamous train, and the trio met Garcia during a bluegrass jam. Apparently the actual invitation to come to San Francisco was extended by Gail Hellund, who was sort of an operations manager (I'm not sure of her official title). Some evidence suggests that Hellund acted as the manager of James And The Good Brothers along with any Dead or New Riders duties. This would fit in with the model of cooperation and expansion outlined above. Gail Hellund's time and skills could be usefully distributed to another enterprise.

 

July 1, 1970 Winnipeg Fairgrounds, Winnipeg, MB (Wed) Festival Express Tour

 

July 4-5, 1970 McMahon Stadium, Calgary, AB (Saturday-Sunday) Festival Express Tour

By the end of the train trip, Ackroyd and the Good Brothers had been invited to San Francisco. Presumably the band played other gigs around Toronto until their Fall arrival in the Bay Area.

James And The Good Brothers in San Francisco, Performance Listing 1970-71

October 15, 1970 The Matrix, San Francisco, CA: James and The Good Brothers (Thursday) "Courtesy of The Grateful Dead"

The first booking we can find for James And The Good Brothers is on Thursday, October 15 at the Matrix. The tiny Matrix, capacity at most 150, while it had been the original San Francisco hippie club, had been bumped aside by larger clubs. By 1970, as I have documented, the Matrix was mainly a musicians' hangout. The most prominent of the musicians who regularly played there was Jerry Garcia, who used weeknights there for jamming explorations with Bill Vitt, John Kahn, Howard Wales and (by October) Merl Saunders. 

 

Garcia's stature at the Matrix was such that a request by the Grateful Dead office to book an unknown out-of-town band would be accepted on its face. At the same time, it's worth noting that the Matrix wasn't booking premier club acts in any case. The most intriguing thing about the notation in the San Francisco Chronicle Datebook listings was that James And The Good Brothers are noted as "Courtesy Of The Grateful Dead." On one hand, this was unprecedented. On the other hand, the sort of tuned-in hippie who went to the Matrix would have heard of the New Riders, so they could probably guess a little about what was going on.

 

The Inn Of The Beginning, at 8201 Old Redwood Highway in Cotati, CA, as it appeared in 2010

October 16-17, 1970 Inn Of The Beginning, Cotati, CA: Cat Mother/James and The Good Brothers (Friday-Saturday)

The Inn Of The Beginning, at 8201 Old Redwood Highway in Cotati wasn't large, but it was still larger than the Matrix. The capacity of the club was about 200, and it was a regular gig for Bay Area bands. The New Riders of The Purple Sage had played there regularly since 1969. So a phone call from the Dead office would surely have gotten James And The Good Brothers booked. In this case, they were opening for Cat Mother. 

 

Cat Mother And The All Night News Boys were a Greenwich Village folk-rock band who had been making their second album (Albion Doo-Wah) at Pacific High Recorders, and had simply decided to stay in the Bay Area. Pacific High Recorders was at 60 Brady Street, right behind the Fillmore West, and would be sold to Alembic in 1971, although they would continue to use the name Pacific High Recorders on occasion.

 

October 23-24, 1970 New Orleans House, Berkeley, CA: Redwing/James and The Good Brothers (Friday-Saturday) "Courtesy of the Grateful Dead"

The New Orleans House, at 1505 San Pablo Avenue in North Berkeley, had been one of the first clubs in the Bay Area to book original rock bands, back in 1966. It had a capacity of around 250, but it wasn't in a central, accessible part of Berkeley, so it was feeling the pressure of the growing competition. The New Orleans House ad in the San Francisco Good Times says JATGB are "Courtesy  Of The Grateful Dead."

 

Redwing was a Sacramento group that had evolved out of a popular 60s band called The New Breed. The best known member was bassist Tim Schmidt, who by 1970 had joined Poco (and would later join The Eagles). Redwing had made an album in 1970 for United Artists, and some of their material had also been released under the band-name Glad.

 

October 26, 1970 Lion's Share, San Anselmo, CA: Janis Joplin's Wake (Monday)

Janis Joplin had died the night of October 5, 1970. As part of her will, she had a gigantic party thrown for her at the Lion's Share in San Anselmo. The Lion's Share was another musician's hangout, and about 10 minutes from downtown San Rafael. The Grateful Dead flew back from the East Coast to perform. In the 2015 interview, Bruce Good mentioned how honored they were to be invited. They had become friendly with Janis on the Festival Express train.

Every hippie in the Bay Area would have wanted an invite to Janis' wake, but James And The Good Brothers actually went. The fact that they got invited was a clear, if sad, indicator that they were part of the extended Grateful Dead family. I don't know if the band actually played, but it's entirely plausible they got up and sang a few songs (and plausible that no one, including the band, remembers for sure).

October 27-November 1, 1970 Troubadour James and The Good Brothers/Alliotta Haynes (Tuesday-Sunday)

Doug Weston's Troubadour in West Hollywood was one of the most important rock nightclubs in the 1970s. The club was essential to launching the careers of numerous iconic singer-songwriters in that era. Among the most prominent were James Taylor, Elton John, Cat Stevens and Kris Kristofferson--and that was just 1970. Yet it is all but entirely forgotten that in August, 1970 Weston opened a San Francisco branch of The Troubadour. Elton John even played there.

 

The San Francisco Troubadour flopped miserably after only four months.  James And The Good Brothers were booked for the final week that the club was open. At that point, probably no other band really wanted the gig. Still, there was an interesting subplot: Troubadour house manager David Allen would re-open the club at 960 Bush Street the next March. James and The Good Brothers were booked for the opening weekend, and they played the Boarding House a number of times throughout 1971 (see below).

I have found no dates for James And The Good Brothers in November. Both Brian and Bruce Good had family in Canada, so it's possible that they took a trip back home.

Update: David Kramer-Smyth confirmed this. An article in the November 20, 1970 Ottawa Journal mentions an upcoming show at Le Hibou Cafe in Ottawa. It also mentions that the group had just played the Crypt and The Riverboat in Toronto.

 

The Lion's Share, at 60 Red Hill Avenue in San Anselmo, sometime in the early 1970s

December 4-5, 1970 Lion's Share, San Anselmo, CA: James and The Good Brothers /The Pipe (Friday-Saturday)

Since the Lion's Share was a musician's hangout, James And The Good Brothers were probably known around town by this time. The Lion's Share sometimes booked prominent bands, but there were plenty of weekends where local acts headlined the club.

 

December 11-12, 1970 Inn Of The Beginning, Cotati, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Pamela (Friday-Saturday)

James And The Good Brothers returned to headline a weekend at the Inn Of The Beginning. They must have been good enough in October for the Inn to give them a chance to co-headline a weekend. Sonoma State College was probably out of session, so it would have been a less high-profile night, but coming back to a club two months later as a weekend headliner was still a healthy sign for the trio.

 

Co-headliner Pamela was almost certainly Pamela Polland. Polland was a singer-songwriter who had moved to Mill Valley after she had been signed to a solo contract by Columbia. Previously, she had been in a Los Angeles duo called Gentle Soul, who had released an album back in 1968. Polland's story is quite interesting (some readers may recognize her subsequent persona "Melba Rounds"), but it's mostly a sidelight to James And The Good Brothers.

A critical detail to the Polland story, however, was her manager Diane Sward (later Diane Rapaport). Sward (1939-2019) was a band manager under the umbrella of the Bill Graham organization from 1969 to '74, and her stories from those days (while also a sidetrack here) are well worth reading. 

 

In one post Sward described what faced local singers who weren't in a loud rock band:

Gigs in Bay Area coffeehouses were easy to get, but they didn’t make a lot of money for anyone, including the performers. They were able to get a few gigs in clubs at 8 or 8:30 p.m., prior to when many rock bands began setting up for a 9:30 show. I told club owners that my band would help warm up the audience, didn’t need a big stage setup (no drums, no big amps, no stage monitors) and would make them enough extra bucks selling drinks to pay us.

However rock fans and acoustic music fans didn’t always mix well. More often than not the audience would start getting impatient around 9:15. “We want Jerry (Garcia); we want Elvin (Bishop) and so on.”

I attended a lot of Lamb gigs and saw such other Bay Area acoustic performers as Lambert & Nuttycombe, Jeffrey Cain and Uncle Vinty. They were all bucking up against rock ‘n roll. The audiences for rock bands were larger; and that meant more money for the club owners.

Sward went on to find unique bookings for her acts, and helped them record as well. Still, her reflections point up an historically unnoticed barrier for James And The Good Brothers. In the 60s and 70s, San Francisco was renowned for breaking new and interesting bands: Jefferson Airplane, The Dead, Big Brother, Sly and The Family Stone, Santana, Tower Of Power and the Doobie Brothers, to name the most prominent. While those groups were not confined to a single genre, they were all loud, danceable bands that could rock the Fillmore and Winterland. 

Starting with the August 1969 release of the Crosby, Stills and Nash album, listeners, radio and record companies expanded their tastes to include rock musicians who, while writing original songs, were quieter. The new breed of singer/songwriters emphasized sincerity, acoustic guitars and sophisticated harmonies. James And The Good Brothers fit right into the vein that would lead groups like America and Seals And Crofts to huge success. A parallel success story at the time was The Band, whose first two albums sold well and got perhaps the best reviews any rock bands ever received. James And The Good Brothers were Canadian, too, so in acoustic way they evoked The Band's countrified harmonies.

 

Musicians from all over America had been coming to San Francisco to make it since the mid-60s, and James And The Good Brothers had relocated along with man others. It turned out, however, that for all its openness, early 70s San Francisco was a terrible place to break acoustic acts. Singer/songwriters who played the Troubadour in West Hollywood did great, but acoustic trios didn't make it out of San Francisco. Diane Sward, for one, had figured this out and was trying to crack the egg, but in the end San Francisco wasn't a good place for acoustic bands. But James And The Good Brothers, nor the Dead's management, would not find that out until later.

 

December 18, 1970 Burbank Auditorium, Santa Rosa Junior College, Santa Rosa, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Victoria/Tim and Jan (Friday)

The Junior College system in California was an outgrowth of both the GI Bill and the massive migration to California during and after World War 2. With numerous ex-GIs able to afford college, and a big population, California had to expand its college options. Not only did the University of California expand, and the State College system, too, but just about every county had a 2-year junior college with open admissions. Residents over 18 could go to college locally, effectively for free, and if they succeeded they could transfer to the State College or UC Systems.

 

In the case of Santa Rosa Junior College, it had existed since 1918, but had fully integrated into the State Junior College system by 1969. It was located downtown at 1501 Mendocino Road. Santa Rosa is in Sonoma County, 50 miles North of San Francisco.

 

A breathless article in the December 17, 1970 Oak Leaf, the Santa Rosa Junior College student newspaper, gives the band the full push (article courtesy of JGMF-transcribed as published)

The Christmas seasons festivities will begin tomorrow in Burbank Auditorium at 4.p.m when the student body of this campus will have the opportunity to hear three farout Canadians who call themselves JAMES AND THE GOOD BROTHERS.

Their manager, Gail, met them on the Festival Express while on a tour of Canada last summer, with the Grateful Dead and persuaded them to give California a go.

The first performance of James and The Good Brothers was two months ago at the Inn Of The Beginning. The audience response was so enthusiastically overwhelming that they are currently in the process of recording their first album.

According to one of the college sponsors of the group, the Grateful Dead, Eric Anderson, Gordon Lightfoot and countless others, who have heard James and the Good Brothers really freak out when they hear them.

The article goes on to say that the show's ticket sales will not even cover the costs, a sign that the school was dipping into its entertainment budget for this. In the early 70s, even Junior Colleges had entertainment budgets, and local bands could be the beneficiaries. It's likely that the fact that all three acts were acoustic, rather than full-out rock and roll, made them more palatable to the college. Tickets for the show were available at the Inn Of The Beginning, so it suggests that the Inn helped Gail Hellund book the band. Now, while I find it pretty likely that Gordon Lightfoot liked James and The Good Brothers, I doubt he would "really freak out" when he heard them. One can't help but suspect that a Mr. Rock Scully was helping to explain things to an eager cub reporter.

 

Although some comments in the article need to be taken with a grain of salt, note that there is already talk of a James And The Good Brothers album. At this exact moment, artists like James Taylor and Cat Stevens were hitting it big, so record companies would have been very interested in their sound. At the same time, the Grateful Dead had just released American Beauty, and with two hit albums in a row, their sponsorship of the band would mean a lot more to a record company.

Opening act "Victoria" (Victoria Domagalski) was a singer-songwriter, also part of the Bill Graham stable. Her debut album, Secret Of The Bloom, had been released on Graham's San Francisco Records label (distributed by Atlantic) in 1970. Victoria was a solo singer/songwriter, and one of the acts often booked by Diane Sward as part of her acoustic packages.

 

December 31, 1970 Winterland, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/Hot Tuna/New Riders of The Purple Sage/James and The Good Brothers (Thursday)

The Grateful Dead headlined at Winterland on New Year's Eve, along with Hot Tuna and the New Riders. At this time, Bill Graham had lost the lease on Winterland, and New Year's Eve was handled by promoter Paul Barrata.  In a subsequent interview in the Harvard Independent (from March 11, 1971), manager Jon McIntire mentioned that James And The Good Brothers played the show. The trio was not on any of the ads, nor appeared in any broadcasts, nor mentioned in any review. Still, it's important to remember that an acoustic trio without a lot of equipment could be fit in during a set change, and a New Year's Eve show was a chance for big exposure. The promoter would have happily accepted James And The Good Brothers upon the Dead's request.

January 21, 1971 Freeborn Hall, UC Davis, Davis, CA: Grateful Dead/New Riders of The Purple Sage/James and The Good Brothers (Thursday)

The Grateful Dead played on a Thursday night at UC Davis, just outside of Sacramento. They were joined by both the New Riders and James and The Good Brothers. While the Dead no longer did the acoustic set and the full "An Evening With The Grateful Dead," they were providing four sets with an acoustic opener.

January 27-28, 1971 Keystone Korner, San Francisco, CA: Big Brother and The Holding Company w/Nick Gravenites/James and The Good Brothers/Gideon and Power (Wednesday-Thursday)

Big Brother and The Holding Company had disintegrated at the end of 1968 when Janis Joplin left the band. Still, the band had reformed at the end of 1969, with the four original (pre-Janis) members and guitarist David Schallock (although James Gurley and Peter Albin had switched to bass and guitar, respectively). They had released a good, but unnoticed album on Columbia in 1970 called Be A Brother. Nick Gravenites was their producer and sometimes sang with them. They were still a name around the Bay Area, but no longer a major act.

 

Keystone Korner was mainly a blues club, although the actual bookings ranged from white rock bands to soul to Chicago blues. Still, just about all the acts were loud and bluesy, and in that respect, James And The Good Brothers may have been a little out of place.

 

Gideon and Power was a sort of Gospel-Rock band featuring singer Gideon Daniels. He would release one album in 1972, and Gideon and Power became a sort of farm team for the Elvin Bishop Group. In later years, Gideon and Power would include backup vocalist Mickey Thomas and organist Melvin Seals, both of whom would join Elvin Bishop sometime later (and then Jefferson Starship and Jerry Garcia Band, respectively).

 

January 29-30, 1971 Inn Of The Beginning, Cotati, CA: Lamb/James and The Good Brothers (Friday-Saturday)

Lamb had initially been a songwriting duo featuring singer and pianist Barbara Lamb and guitarist Bob Swanson. They were another act managed by Diane Sward, and this booking fit her idea of pairing acoustic acts in nightclubs. I think Lamb had a bass player and a drummer by this time, but I'm not sure of that.

 

I think by this time James And The Good Brothers had been signed to Columbia and started recording. The absence of any shows in the next month, plus some other clues, suggest that the band recorded throughout the month of February. Their Columbia album would be released in November, 1971. The producer was long-time Grateful Dead engineer Betty Cantor. She shared the engineering duties with Bob Matthews, so the Dead had assigned the A-Team that had delivered Live/Dead and Workingman's Dead. Initial recording took place at Pacific High Recorders, at 60 Brady Street behind the Fillmore West. Later, the studio would be purchased by Alembic and used primarily for mixing. 

 

In late 1970, Columbia Records had signed the New Riders Of The Purple Sage. Columbia boss Clive Davis was high on Garcia (to coin a phrase). He had apparently tried to sign the Grateful Dead when their contract had come up in 1969, but Lenny Hart had extended the Warner Brothers deal for a few more albums. Davis was playing a long game, though. In his cosmology, the key to the Grateful Dead was Garcia--he wasn't wrong--so Davis took numerous steps to show Garcia favor. Not only did Davis sign the New Riders, a Columbia imprint (Douglas Records) had also signed Howard Wales to do an album. Columbia had also helped finance Mickey Hart's studio, according to Billboard. 

On one hand, we can see Columbia's signing of James And The Good Brothers as a continuation of Clive Davis' ongoing efforts to make Garcia feel wanted when the Dead's contract renewal came up. Although the Dead surprised everybody by going it alone in '72, when Grateful Dead Records crumpled a few years later, Clive Davis--by now running Arista Records--finally got his opportunity. It took a while, but eventually the Grateful Dead had a massive hit with In The Dark, and sold a lot of other albums in between. So whether or not Garcia specifically recommended James And The Good Brothers to Clive Davis, we know that Davis had a vested interest in making Garcia see him favorably. 

In 1970 and '71, Clive Davis signed the New Riders, James And The Good Brothers and the Rowan Brothers, all San Francisco bands with intimate ties to Jerry Garcia. In 1976 he got his man. Yet, to give Davis credit, he was also a pretty good record man. For one thing, the first four New Riders albums were pretty successful (NRPS, Powerglide, Gypsy Cowboy and Panama Red). Certainly Columbia turned a profit on those albums. So whatever Davis' motives for signing the Riders, it turned out pretty well financially for Columbia. 

As for James And The Good Brothers, they were not really a success and broke up in 1972, as we will see. Afterwards, however, Brian and Bruce Good returned to Canada and teamed up with their younger  brother Larry, and had a pretty successful career in Canada. So when Clive Davis had signed them in late 1970, he must have heard the talent and appeal. In that sense, Davis' signing of the band was retroactively justified by the Good Brothers' ultimate Canadian success. So while Garcia's "sponsorship" was essential for getting James And The Good Brothers' signing to Columbia, their own talent ultimately proved that the commercial sense of that investment, even if Columbia itself didn't benefit.

 

As for the album itself, I am pretty sure that Columbia was not pleased with the finished product, and took James And The Good Brothers to Toronto to re-record some different songs, without Bob and Betty. Contractually, Betty Cantor's name had to be on the album, but the record company seems to have overruled her mixes. Some cryptical details suggest that Jerry Garcia probably played on the initial sessions, but I suspect that any tracks that he played on were re-recorded in Toronto.

 

February 5-6, 1971 New Orleans House, Berkeley, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Abel (Friday-Saturday)  

A picture and listing from the Santa Rosa Press-Democrat of February 15, 1971 for the Saturday night (February 20) show at the Veterans Memorial

February 20, 1971 Veterans Memorial Building, Santa Rosa, CA: Bronze Hog/Cat Mother and The All-Night Newsboys/James and The Good Brothers/Abraxas Rising (Saturday)

Ace researcher David Kramer-Smyth found this date. All of these bands were local. Bronze Hog were effectively the "house band" at Inn Of The Beginning.

February 25-28, 1971 Fillmore West, San Francisco, CA: New Riders of The Purple Sage/Boz Scaggs/James and The Good Brothers (Thursday-Sunday)

By early 1971, the Fillmore West was as legendary as ever, but it was starting to become too small for the booming rock market. Fillmore West's 2500-capacity had been 60% larger than the original Fillmore, but Winterland was over twice as big as the Fillmore West. Bigger bands didn't headline the Fillmore West as often as they had. They would still play for Bill Graham, but at bigger local venues.

At this time, the New Riders of The Purple Sage did not have an album. Save for some brief radio broadcasts, and a few demos on KSAN, the only people who had heard the New Riders had seen them in concert. Of course, Jerry Garcia was still their pedal steel guitar player. Boz Scaggs had released a fine debut on Atlantic in 1969, and he had a new release (Moments, on Columbia) coming out in March. So Boz was known, but he wasn't yet a major artist either. Thus the 4-day weekend at the Fillmore West was not anchored by acts that were currently big hits, either on FM radio or on tour.

One of these Fillmore West shows was written up in the suburban Hayward Daily Review by "KG", the team of Kathie Staska and George Mangum. The duo probably saw the Saturday (February 27) show. The most remarkable detail of the review was that James And The Good Brothers were joined by Jack Casady on "balalaika bass," Spencer Dryden on drums and Jerry Garcia on banjo. For one thing, the rhythm section would have helped the band go over in a rock hall like Fillmore West. 

For another, Garcia's presence means that he knew the songs, so he must have been around for the recording of the album, or at least some of it. This public performance is the key reason that I think Garcia played on the album sessions. He is thanked on the album, but not listed in the credits. On the other hand, the tracks with Toronto musicians include a banjo player (younger brother Larry Good), which is why I think the tracks with Garcia were re-recorded. The album would not come out for another 8 months, so Clive Davis must have been unhappy with the results. I should add that in such circumstances, record company complaints were generally oriented toward the actual sound of the recording--particularly focused on how it would sound on the radio--rather than the musical quality itself. To a record guy, if the sound wasn't right, it wouldn't matter how Garcia or anyone else played on the tracks. 

There's every reason to assume that Garcia played with James And The Good Brothers all four nights at Fillmore West. Thus Garcia was following the model of the New Riders, playing with them to let them benefit from the glow of his status. Garcia would do the same a few months later with the Rowan Brothers, playing a few local gigs and then joining them for their Fillmore West show when they opened for the Grateful Dead. The Rowan Brothers had also been signed to Columbia by Clive Davis. Was it a coincidence that Garcia played a similar role for all three Columbia bands? I doubt it.

March 7, 1971 Burl Theater, Boulder Creek, CA: Commander Cody and The Lost Planet Airmen/James and The Good Brothers (Sunday) 2pm show

By 1971 Commander Cody and His Lost Planet Airmen were a popular local band, and had probably already been signed to Paramount Records. But they had not yet recorded their debut album (it would be released in November '71), so the Airmen weren't that well known outside of the East Bay. Cody and his crew had already played with the Dead and New Riders many times, however, so linking up with James And The Good Brothers was pretty logical.

Boulder Creek is on Highway 9 in the Santa Cruz Mountains, 13 winding miles from downtown Santa Cruz, about halfway to Saratoga. I don't know anything about the Burl Theater, but since Boulder Creek is in a forest of Redwood trees, it's easy to guess. At the time, the area was full of hippies, loners, bikers, pot growers and other peculiar characters. Many of the residents would have fit more than one of these categories. The show was booked for 2pm, leaving plenty of time for the band to get to Berkeley for their show later that evening.

March 7, 1971 Mandrake's, Berkeley, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Lizard (Sunday)

Mandrake's, at 1048 University Avenue in Berkeley, was near the corner of University and San Pablo Avenue, nearly two miles from campus. During World War 2, with the Oakland and Richmond shipyards booming, tired workers with money in their pockets needed to relax. San Pablo Avenue was known as "Music Row," with clubs from one end to another. Mandrake's was a remaining legacy. The 200-seat room had opened in 1965, initially a pool hall that sometimes booked music. It focused on blues and jazz, initially, but rapidly expanded to include rock. The little club served beer, wine and food, and was a good place for bands to build an audience.

March 10-11, 1971 Mandrake's, Berkeley, CA: Cat Mother/James and The Good Brothers (Wednesday-Thursday)

March 12-13, 1971 New Orleans House, Berkeley, CA: Cat Mother/James and The Good Brothers (Friday-Saturday)

Cat Mother, a much more established band, played four nights in Berkeley, supported by James And The Good Brothers. The two clubs were about a half mile apart, both on San Pablo Avenue.

 

The Boarding House, at 960 Bush St in San Francisco

March 26-28, 1971 Boarding House, San Francisco, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Melissa (Friday-Sunday)

James And The Good Brothers had been the last group to headline at Doug Weston's ill-fated San Francisco Troubadour, back in October. It must have gone well, since when the club opened up four months later as The Boarding House, they were the first group to headline the new club. Weston's house manager, David Allen, had re-opened the room as an "acoustic music salon," in his words. Over the next year, the Boarding House became a nexus for local acoustic acts who didn't really fit at noisy rock clubs. 

The Boarding House was at 960 Bush Street (at Taylor), and I have written about its opening at some length. The Boarding House was an important club for the San Francisco music scene throughout the 1970s. In this initial version, however, the club was in the same space as The Troubadour, a downstairs dining room with long tables and a stage at one end, seating about 225. Most Bay Area rock fans from the era recall something different. That is because somewhere around 1972, Allen moved the club upstairs into what was initially called "The Boarding House Theater." The Theater was an elegant bowl-shaped room, with great sightlines and good sound. It had the same address, though, so the shows that we all recall are from the upstairs room, not the downstairs one. The downstairs room was still occasionally used for comedy during the later era.

 

April 2, 1971 Inn Of The Beginning, Cotati, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Loose Gravel (Friday)

April 3, 1971 Inn Of The Beginning, Cotati, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Clover (Saturday)

James And The Good Brothers returned to the Inn Of The Beginning. On Friday night, they were paired with Loose Gravel, a band led by former Charlatans guitarist Michael Wilhelm. On Saturday night, it was the Marin band Clover. At the time, Clover was a quartet led by guitarists John McFee and Alex Call. They would release two albums on Fantasy (their 1970 self-titled debut and 1971's Fourty Niner) before they were dropped.

April 6-11, 1971 The Boarding House, San Francisco, CA: James And The Good Brothers/Jo Ellen Yester (Tuesday-Sunday)

Things must have gone well in March, because James And The Good Brothers returned for another week. 

April 29, 1971 Ives Hall, Sonoma State College, Rohnert Park, CA: Rick Taylor/CiCi/James and The Good Brothers/Lamb Peace Week Folk Festival (Thursday)

David Kramer-Smyth found a link to the Peace Week event.

 

May 29-30, 1971 Winterland, San Francisco, CA: Grateful Dead/New Riders of The Purple Sage/RJ Fox/James and The Good Brothers (Saturday-Sunday)

Bill Graham had recaptured the rights to Winterland, and he had booked the Dead to headline two shows on Friday and Saturday, May 28-29. Support acts were the New Riders Of The Purple Sage, James and The Good Brothers and RJ Fox. Once again, this was effectively another Evening With The Grateful Dead, with the exception that James And The Good Brothers were doing the acoustic set, instead of Garcia and Weir. 

RJ Fox was a vocal trio with songwriters Joel Siegel and Richard Hovey, along with singer Sherry Fox. The trio apparently had remarkable harmonies, and had somehow talked their way into Wally Heider Studios in 1970 when David Crosby was recording. Crosby and producer Stephen Barncard were so impressed that they got them signed to Atlantic. Barncard would produce an album, scheduled for Fall '71, but due to politics at Atlantic the record was scrapped (it was eventually released some decades later). RJ Fox would split up, and Sherry Fox would go onto become the lead singer of the band Cookin' Mama. In 1973, Siegel and Fox would reunite as Oasis. 

Thus the entire booking was part of the Grateful Dead "Family." RJ Fox was present courtesy of Crosby and Barncard, but those two were family members if anyone was. As it happened, Garcia fell ill. The Friday, May 28 show was canceled, and the shows were moved to May 29 and 30 (Saturday and Sunday). Garcia did not play with the New Riders on Saturday night, a sign of how poorly he must have felt [update: as noted by LIA in the Comments, while James And The Good Brothers were advertised, they may not have played either night].

I have been able to find no James And The Good Brothers bookings from June through August. My assumption is that the band returned to Toronto to re-record parts of the album. Of course, since the Good Brothers were from Toronto, they probably had a vested interest in spending a few months there. Based on the credits, at least three tracks seem to have been recorded (or re-recorded) in Toronto. 

 

update: David Kramer-Smyth is on the case

July 27-31, 1971 Le Hibou Cafe, Ottawa, ON, Canada: James And The Good Brothers (Tuesday-Sunday)

We now know that the band was definitely in Canada. They were favorably reviewed in the Ottawa Citizen and the Ottawa Journal.

 

Remarkably, DKS also found the Fictitious Business Name Statement for James And The Good Brothers, published in the Santa Rosa Press-Democrat of August 1, 1971. The address given is 8201 Old Redwood Highway, the site of the Inn Of The Beginning. IOTB manager Ward Maillard is listed as their manager. This tells us when the band had to "get serious" as a California business, with an album on the way.

The James And The Good Brothers album was released on Columbia in November 1971

September 5, 1971 Pacific High Recorders (Alembic Studios), San Francisco, CA: James and The Good Brothers (Sunday)

James And The Good Brothers reappeared in San Francisco, broadcast live on KSAN-fm, the biggest rock station in Northern California. At this time, KSAN had a regular Sunday night show where rock bands would perform live in the studio. KSAN supremo Tom Donahue would announce the studio as Pacific High Recording (at 60 Brady), but in fact by this time it was actually called Alembic Studios. I don't know exactly why there was this subterfuge, but I assume that Alembic did not want to attract attention, so that riffraff would not come to the studio "looking for Jerry." By using a name that didn't exist, it added a layer of obscurity to the location.

The weekly KSAN broadcasts have been the source of many great tapes from the era (Deadheads will be most familiar with the February 6, 1972 KSAN broadcast with Merl Saunders). On this particular night there were three bands. The headliner, so to speak, was Van Morrison, who played a 90-minute set with his band that was for the ages. The highlight was a cover of Bob Dylan's "Just Like A Woman" which was played on KSAN regularly for the next decade. The middle act was Joy Of Cooking, a Berkeley band with a good album on Capitol.

While KSAN controlled the broadcasts, there were always complicated record company politics behind the scenes. We don't know what they were of course, but considering that James And The Good Brothers did not have an album, their presence couldn't have been a coincidence. Of course, they were signed to Columbia and managed by the Grateful Dead organization. So whether there was an explicit quid pro quo (such as Columbia purchasing ads) or just some mutual backscratching, connections count. 

For us, however, the high quality 53-minute tape gives us a clear picture of how James And The Good Brothers sounded. The band has nice harmonies and an easy flow, and they are right in line with popular groups like America or Seals and Crofts. Their Canadian accents "de-countrify" the essentially country sounds. Since hippies and rednecks were not aligned at the time, the distinction was important. It's no surprise that Garcia liked their playing, nor that Clive Davis wanted to sign them. Success didn't happen, because the record industry is always a crapshoot, but it wasn't due to lack of talent.

 

September 7-12, 1971 Boarding House, San Francisco, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Cris Willliamson/Uncle Vinty (Tuesday-Sunday)

James And The Good Brothers returned to headline another week at The Boarding House. It had to have helped to have played an hour on the biggest rock station in San Francisco. They were supported by Cris Williamson and Uncle Vinty, both of them further examples of the types of interesting acoustic acts that were struggling to find a foothold.

Cris Williamson, from Deadwood, SD, had put out three folk albums on Vanguard as a teenager in 1964-65. By 1971, she had released an album on Ampex, recorded in San Francisco and New York. She was getting the typical singer/songwriter push of the era, but getting nowhere. At this time, she was booked as "Chris" Williamson, whether by choice or not isn't clear. In 1975, having been dropped by Ampex, Williamson founded Olivia Records, a label run for women that was run by women. Olivia Records released excellent music for its own audience. For all Williamson's talent, the music industry in San Francisco (nor elsewhere) was unable to find that audience.

Uncle Vinty (Vinton Medbury, 1947-94) was essentially a performance artist who played the piano. He sang and played the piano, told jokes and did magic tricks. He often performed in a Viking hat. Originally from Rhode Island, he had come out to San Francisco around 1971. He ultimately ended up in Milwaukee, although he continued to tour around. He died early, but is fondly remembered on the internet. Uncle Vinty didn't fit into any pre-existing box, however, and San Francisco music scene didn't really know what to make of him.

 

September 17-20, 1971 Lion's Share, San Anselmo, CA: James and The Good Brothers/Cris Williamson/Uncle Vinty (Thursday-Monday)

The same bill went on for four days at the Lion's Share. The ads are confusing, and James And The Good Brothers may have done a night at the New Orleans House during this weekend.

 

September ?, 1971 The Ash Grove, Los Angeles, CA: James And The Good Brothers/Carol Hunter

David Kramer-Smyth found a review in a late September LA Free Press of a Good Brothers show at the The Ash Grove. The Ash Grove, at 8162 Melrose Avenue, had opened in 1958 and had been Los Angeles' premier folk club. By 1971, it had rock and blues bands at well, but it was being outshone by other clubs in the area. The Ash Grove would close in 1973, and a comedy club called The Improv took its place.

At this point, the performing trail of James And The Good Brothers goes cold. We know that Columbia released their debut album in November. Various websites say that the band toured around the country in 1972. The Good Brothers website mentions memories of playing the Troubadour in West Hollywood with Mother Earth and John Hammond. It's very hard to find out historical bookings at the Troubadour--I seem to be the only person who has tried--but I can't find a trace of a date for them in 1971 or '72. That in itself doesn't mean anything, but it makes it harder to track the band. Bookings at the Troubadour were generally two acts for six days (Tuesdays through Sundays), so they probably played two different weeks with different headliners.

Per the websites, James And The Good Brothers didn't like touring around. Also, the album didn't go anywhere, and it was very hard for a band to get much traction if their record company had lost interest in them. Bruce and Brian Good wanted to return to Canada and their families, so the band broke up. Jerry Garcia and the Grateful Dead had heard them, recognized their talent and kick-started their careers. Since the band had met Garcia in July 1970, James And The Good Brothers had released an album, played all over the Bay Area and then the country. That was a bigger bite of the apple than most bands got. The Grateful Dead would try the model one more time with the Rowan Brothers (the subject of a future post), before Garcia and the crew decided on an entirely new and different model for building their musical empire.

Pretty Ain't Good Enough, the 1977 lp by the Good Brothers

Aftermath

Bruce and Brian Good returned to Richmond Hill, outside of Toronto. They joined with their younger brother Larry Good, who mainly played banjo. Initially, they started gigging around in 1972 as The Good Brothers. By 1975, they had a thriving career in Canada. They put out numerous albums, many of them went gold in Canada,  and they won various awards in a career that extended over 40 years. Now, Canada isn't the States, and success there is on a narrower scale. Still, the goal of almost every professional musician is to make a living making music, and not have to get a real job, and the Good Brothers did that.

As if the Good Brothers success wasn't enough, if you will recall, singer Margaret McQueen had left the Kinfolk and married Bruce Good. Their sons Dallas and Travis Good formed The Sadies in 1994. They started recording in 1998. They, too, have had a thriving career. They have recorded numerous albums, as well as collaborating with artists like Neil Young, Neko Case and John Doe. 

In mid-72, when James And The Good Brothers broke up, James Ackroyd returned to California. Initially, he was the bass player for Canadian guitarist/songwriter David Rea and his band Slewfoot. This, too, was a Grateful Dead connection, as Bob Weir (of all people) had co-produced Rea's Slewfoot album for Columbia in 1973. Ackroyd stayed on as Rea's bassist until at least the end of 1973. By late 1974, Ackroyd was fronting the local band James And The Mercedes, which included Frankie Weir (Bob's then-wife). Ackroyd seems to have died in 1999, fondly remembered by his friends and former bandmates.